Diary of a rail fan in Kansai,Japan(Ver.2)

About world's rail news, general news, my train pictures, and travel diary)

My twitter account(本サイト主のツイッター)
List of my travel diary My train photoes The other contents

Fukushima caused mutant butterflies: Scientists

Citation: http://www.straitstimes.com/breaking-news/technology/story/fukushima-caused-mutant-butterflies-scientists

This conclusion led by the results is dubious. Original paper is available at http://www.nature.com/srep/2012/120809/srep00570/full/srep00570.html

First, when we see figure 3 on the linked paper, F2 generation in Motomiya indicates extremely highest abnormality rate despite the fact that Motomiya is farther than Hirono from Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plants ,and mountains lie between the nuclear power plants and Motomiya.

Second, figure 1 and figure 4 are also dubious. The problem found in figure 1d is that three dots locating on larger than 1μSv/h cannot be approximated by linear function. Four dots on larger than 0.4μSv/h on figure 4b seem to have the similar problem.

Surely, we can say that radioactive fallout affected P generation and F1 generation directory. But, it is doubtful that the abnormality genes were trandmitted to offsprings.